Sabeer Bhatia on India’s Failure Stigma: Why Innovation Needs Risk

Introduction
In a candid interview, Sabeer Bhatia, the co‑founder of the pioneering email service Hotmail, warned that India’s deep‑seated stigma around failure is choking the nation’s capacity to experiment and innovate. While Hotmail’s launch in 1996 reshaped global communication, Bhatia’s later ventures have struggled to gain traction, a reality he attributes to a cultural climate that penalises missteps rather than celebrates learning. The conversation shines a light on how societal attitudes, educational norms, and funding practices intersect to create an environment where aspiring entrepreneurs hesitate to take bold risks. This article examines the roots of that stigma, its impact on the Indian startup ecosystem, and the steps needed to foster a more resilient, failure‑friendly mindset.

From Hotmail to a New Generation of Start‑ups

Hotmail’s meteoric rise made Bhatia a household name, but his subsequent projects—ranging from a mobile payments platform to an AI‑driven health‑tech venture—have not replicated that success. What have you done since Hotmail? is a question that now reverberates across Indian boardrooms, reflecting both admiration for his early breakthrough and frustration at the limited follow‑up. Bhatia argues that the problem is not a lack of talent; rather, it is the pervasive fear of public failure that discourages even seasoned founders from pursuing untested ideas.

Cultural aversion to failure in India

India’s education system traditionally rewards rote learning and high‑stakes examinations, leaving little room for trial‑and‑error. A 2024 survey by the Startup India initiative found that 68% of respondents felt “social embarrassment” was a greater deterrent than financial risk when a venture flopped. This sentiment is reinforced by family expectations and media narratives that celebrate overnight success while marginalising stories of perseverance after setbacks.

• Family pressure: Young entrepreneurs often face direct questioning about their career choices, with failure perceived as a personal flaw.
• Media bias: Headlines focus on unicorns, rarely covering the iterative journeys behind them.
• Funding mindset: Investors sometimes demand proof of concept before committing, limiting early‑stage experimentation.

Impact on the startup ecosystem

The reluctance to embrace failure has tangible economic consequences. According to a report by NASSCOM released in March 2025, India’s startup failure rate rose to 23% in 2024, up from 17% in 2020, as founders opted for low‑risk, incremental projects. The table below lists the most notable startup closures between 2023 and 2025, illustrating a trend toward premature shutdowns rather than strategic pivots.

These closures often stem from a premature decision to abandon a venture rather than iterating based on feedback—an approach that runs counter to the “fail fast, learn faster” mantra championed by global innovators.

Calls for a paradigm shift

Industry leaders, including Bhatia, are urging a cultural reset. He suggests three actionable steps: educational reform that integrates design thinking and entrepreneurship into curricula; media responsibility to highlight stories of resilience; and investment policies that reward long‑term vision over short‑term metrics. Several Indian incubators have begun to adopt “failure‑friendly” programs, offering mentorship that reframes setbacks as data points. The government’s recent Startup India Action Plan 2025 also proposes tax incentives for companies that reinvest in failed ventures, signaling a policy-level acknowledgment of the issue.

By normalising the narrative around failure, India can unlock a wave of experimentation akin to the early days of Silicon Valley, where every misstep was a stepping stone toward breakthrough innovation.

Conclusion
Sabeer Bhatia’s reflections expose a fundamental paradox: a nation brimming with talent yet shackled by a fear of failure. The data from recent startup closures underscores how this stigma translates into tangible economic loss. However, with coordinated efforts across education, media, and finance, the cultural script can be rewritten. Embracing failure as a learning tool will not only honour the spirit of pioneers like Bhatia but also pave the way for the next generation of Indian innovators to experiment boldly, fail openly, and ultimately succeed on a larger scale.

Image by: Jakub Zerdzicki
https://www.pexels.com/@jakubzerdzicki